I played hooky from the AAG conference for a day to explore Manhattan and I happened to come across an occupy protest. I took a lot of pictures and if you’re interested, you can see them here. I was on my way back to my hotel when I realized that I was walking through the East Village and decided to take a detour to find Tompkins Square Park. I always like to check out parks when I’m visiting a new place and I was interested in this particular one because of its history as a site of contestation during the 1980s when the neighborhood was rapidly gentrifying. I learned about it when I read From Urban Village to East Village: The Battle for New York’s Lower East Side by Janet Abu-Lughod for a class a few semesters ago.
I have to say, I was inspired by what I found there. Things started to wrap up soon after I arrived, but what I saw was a really diverse group of people coming together to share information and stories, play music and sing, make signs, read poetry, and meet friends. I’m sure there were also curious residents and tourists there who, like me, wandered by on accident.
I was drawn in by the energy of the crowd and found that the overall message of the event was clear: the concentration of wealth and power in the hands of the wealthiest one percent of the population is antithetical to democracy and to the interests of the vast majority of the population. Whether you agree or disagree with this general message, I think it should be seen as a positive thing that people have strong beliefs, they’re speaking up, and they are out there trying to do something to make the world a better place for everyone.
I’m aware of the criticisms of occupy protests and protesters, but I think in any
large group it’s likely to find some who do or say things that don’t help further the group’s larger purpose. On this particular occasion though, what I saw in Tompkins Square Park was a group of people exercising first amendment rights and expressing dissatisfaction with the status quo in a peaceful, respectful, and, I think, powerful way.
A lot of people find protests distasteful, but the fact is that occupying public space is one of the few means people have of raising consciousness and accessing power. Even in this age of mass-communication, coming together in a physical space is still
important. It forces people to take notice and one thing that I think is already happening at least partly as a result of the occupy movement is that more people are thinking and talking about class. Instead of attributing poverty to the personal failures of the poor in a way that suggests they simply haven’t worked hard enough to pull themselves up by their bootstraps, more people are thinking about class in a complex way. Structural explanations for the growing gap between the haves and have-nots are at least on the table. This is a big deal.
I’ve heard opinions being voiced from people who don’t like the “we are the 99%” slogan and resent being lumped in with what they see as a group of lazy and ungrateful hippies out there causing a ruckus and demanding more than their fair share. However, the slogan doesn’t imply that the movement represents the views of the 99%. It is simply referencing the distribution of wealth and power in this country.
Occupy protesters are working under the assumption that we can do better as a society than accept the concentration of wealth and power in the hands of a few. They want a better world for all of us and I applaud everyone that is out there speaking up, dreaming big, and having hope that a more socially just future is possible.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.